• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
  • Recommended: Fighting to save Africa's rhinos
  • Recommended: Sisters, separated for 17 years, find each other at high school track meet
  • Recommended: No cellphone, no Wi-Fi: Living in America's quietest place
  • Recommended: Two best friends, ages 6 and 7, raise $200,000 to fight rare disease

A narrative of the broadcast day and a window into the editorial process at NBC Nightly News

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • Advertise | AdChoices
    Updated
    4
    days
    ago

    White House releases additional documents related to Benghazi response

    One hundred pages of emails were passed out by the White House Wednesday as the Obama administration tried to put an end to the long simmering dispute over what took place when the American compound in Benghazi was attacked. NBC's Peter Alexander reports.

    Michael O'Brien writes
    Follow @mpoindc

     

    Under increasing scrutiny from congressional Republicans, the White House on Wednesday released copies of emails and other additional supporting documents related to its response to last fall’s attack on a U.S. diplomatic post in Benghazi, Libya.

    The White House released the materials in the wake of Republicans’ clamor for more information about how the Obama administration crafted its explanation for the incident, which came at the height of last year’s campaign season, and resulted in the deaths of four Americans, including U.S. Ambassador Christopher Stevens.

    The emails convey different parts of the administration -- the White House, the State Department, and the CIA -- trading drafts of talking points for use not just by representatives of the administration, but also by members of Congress.

    Read part one of the White House emails (.pdf)

    From the very first draft, the talking points included references to "Islamic extremists" who might have participated in the attack.

    The most significant changes involved removing references to Ansar al-Sharia to not hinder the investigation into the attack, and changing reference to the Benghazi location to a "mission" or "diplomatic post," rather than a consulate.

    Those talking points, though, were subjected to scrutiny and a series of tweaks from different agencies to ensure the talking points did not get out in front of investigators, who did not yet appear to have a full grasp of the underpinnings of the attack at that point.

    The documents released by the White House indicated that then-CIA Deputy Director Michael Morell voiced similar concerns to those from State Department officials and that the same intelligence analysts who drafted the original talking points were comfortable with the language included in the edits, NBC's Peter Alexander reported.

    On page 95 of the documents released Wednesday, an email appears to show that then-CIA Director David Petraeus wasn't completely sold on releasing the talking points, writing: "No mention of the cable to Cairo, either? Frankly, I'd just as soon not use this, then ... NSS's call, to be sure; however, this is certainly not what Vice Chairman Ruppersberger was hoping to get for unclas use. Regardless, thx for the great work."

    A congressional hearing last week, where whistleblowers took issue with the administration’s initial explanation that the attacks were the spontaneous outgrowth of an unrelated protest (and not a terrorist attack) gave rise to new demands for more information from the administration.

    Read part two of the White House emails (.pdf)

    Republicans took the emails as a validation of their criticism of the White House for making more changes to its talking points than the administration had originally let on.

    “The seemingly political nature of the State Department’s concerns raises questions about the motivations behind these changes and who at the State Department was seeking them. This release is long overdue and there are relevant documents the Administration has still refused to produce,” said Brendan Buck, a spokesman for House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio. “We hope, however, that this limited release of documents is a sign of more cooperation to come.”

    President Barack Obama has dismissed Republicans’ interest in the administration’s evolving explanation for the attack as a “sideshow,” as recently as this Monday.

    “The whole issue of talking points, frankly, throughout this process has been a sideshow,” he said. “What we have been very clear about throughout was that immediately after this event happened, we were not clear who exactly had carried it out, how it had occurred, what the motivations were.”

    Underlying Republicans’ interest in the Benghazi matter – at which they’ve kept now for six months – is a suspicion that the administration clouded the reality of the attack so as to not damage Obama’s prospects for re-election.

    “The president ran out the clock and he won the election,” Sen. Lindsey Graham, S.C., a chief Republican critic of Obama’s on Benghazi, said Tuesday on Fox News. “He was able to get Benghazi behind him in terms of electoral politics, but it won't go away.”

    Meanwhile, U.S. government officials said investigators have identified a person who played a central role in the attack in Benghazi, and that federal criminal charges against that person will soon be made public. The person to be named in the charges is not yet in U.S. custody, one official said.

    Word of that progress in the investigation followed a statement by Attorney General Eric Holder, who told the House Judiciary Committee Wednesday that the Justice Department has taken "definitive, concrete action" to bring people to justice who were responsible for the attack.

    "We have been aggressive and we are in a good position. Definitive action has been taken," Holder said, though he declined to be more specific. 

    "We will be prepared shortly to reveal what we have done," he said.

    NBC News' Pete Williams and Jonathan Dienst contributed to this report.

     

    This story was originally published on Wed May 15, 2013 5:01 PM EDT

    886 comments

    Why do I get the feeling that releasing these additional e-mails will have the same effect on the Republicans and various other Obama hating loons out there that releasing Obama's long-form birth certificate had on the birther trash?

    Show more
    Explore related topics: white-house, capitol-hill, featured, updated, benghazi, nightly-news, first-read, appfeatured
  • 12
    Apr
    2013
    5:50pm, EDT

    Share your #BigIdea with NBC Nightly News

    Orchard Gardens, a school in Roxbury, Mass., had been plagued by bad test scores and violence -- but one principal's idea to fire the security guards and hire art teachers is helping turn it around. NBC's Katy Tur reports.

    Do you know any people or programs that are helping your community in a brilliant way? NBC Nightly News wants to hear about their innovative ideas. Use the hashtag #BigIdea @nbcnightlynews to tell us how they are tackling the challenges that exist in our world and providing solutions.

    Check out an example below -- this Big Idea aired on Nightly News April 25:

    Up to one in four children in America have an undiagnosed vision disorder. An eye surgeon says he's found a better way, a revolutionary new exam. NBC's Diana Alvear reports.

     

    You can submit a video, send us photos or simply write a description. Contact us on Twitter @nbcnightlynews, via Facebook or Instagram.

    Your ideas may be featured online -- or on our broadcast.

    8 comments

    While i posted my 3 #BigIdeas on the Twitter feed, it is impossible to explain complex ideas in 140 characters. The first idea I have worked on is a turbine designed wind generation system which is light weight and can be mounted on rooftops, either for home or Industrial use. The second Idea I have …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: featured, nightly-news, bigidea
  • 4
    Apr
    2013
    8:19pm, EDT

    MLK and me: How rookie photographer captured history

    Vernon Matthews / Commercial Appeal / Landov

    Photographer Richard Copley in Memphis on March 18, 1968. In his first paid job as a photographer, Copley was sent to the Mason Temple, where the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. rallied a large crowd of sanitation workers. It was the same location where King would later deliver his famous "Mountaintop" speech.

    NBC News

    Photographer Richard Copley with the Rev. Cleophus Smith, who was a young man when he participated in the sanitation workers' strike in 1968.

    By Christina Caron, NBC News

    Richard Copley was just 22 when he got his first paid job as a photographer. But that assignment propelled him into one of the most significant historical events of the 20th century -- and his career.

    “I had no idea what I was stepping into,” he told NBC News during his first media interview from his home in Fisherville, Tenn. “I guess the biggest story of my life and ironically the first.”

    As the photographer for the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) union, Copley was initially asked to attend the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s March 18, 1968, speech in Memphis, Tenn., (pictured above) where the civil rights leader spoke to thousands of sanitation workers who were fighting for better pay and improved safety standards after two Memphis garbage collectors were crushed to death by their truck’s trash compactor.

    Richard Copley

    The most famous of Richard Copley's sanitation strike photos featured the iconic "I Am a Man" posters carried by striking members of Memphis Local 1733 during the march led by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. on March 28, 1968.

    King promised to come back and lead a protest across the city, and on March 28, he did. At the march Copley captured what is now his most famous image: the sea of signs reading, “I Am a Man.” It didn’t take long, however, for things to turn violent.

    “You could hear the glass breaking.… I knew all hell was breaking loose. I will have to say it was exhilarating and terrifying all at once,” said Copley, who got pepper-sprayed during the event. 

    Richard Copley

    The National Guard arrived in Memphis on March 29, 1968, after the sanitation workers' strike turned violent.

    King was quickly pulled out of the protest as the violence escalated, and the next day the National Guard showed up.

    “It was frightening – it looked like a war zone. It was just a show of force, obviously, and ... in my mind it was overreaching. But on the other hand you have to consider the time – it was 1968, and there had been riots in other cities, so I’m sure the 'powers that be' thought it was necessary,” Copley said.

    During the peaceful march held on March 29, Copley shot the image that would become his favorite, the one he called “Dignity”: a photo of two men holding poster boards in their best Sunday attire.

    That combo of their formal dress and “the stern looks on their faces” has always stood out in Copley’s mind, he said.  

    Richard Copley

    Sanitation workers the Rev. Theodore Hibbler, left, and Ted Brown march in downtown Memphis on March 29, 1968, the day after the famous sanitation strike march led by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was shattered by violence.

    King returned to Memphis on April 3 and was assassinated the following day from the balcony of the Lorraine Motel. 

    Richard Copley

    The King family at the April 8, 1968, memorial march for the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., which was attended by an estimated 42,000 people and led by his widow, Coretta Scott King.

    Now, 45 years later, the 67-year-old photographer still has a camera in his hand. Now, though, instead of a 35mm, he shoots video in 1080i HD. As a freelance photographer, his work has appeared on several network news broadcasts, including "Nightly News with Brian Williams."  

    Although he has covered several major events such as 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina, Copley says his most memorable assignment was in Memphis in 1968.

     “What these men did was incredible,” he said. “They were courageous. This was 1968, … and to do what they did makes them heroes.” 

    Richard Copley’s photography is currently being featured at the National Civil Rights Museum in Memphis, Tenn. The exhibit will be moved to Memphis City Hall later this month. 

     

    Richard Copley

    During the April 8, 1968, memorial march to honor the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., who had been shot four days earlier, Richard Copley captured this image of a white man holding an African-American child. Labor groups from all over the country showed up to pay tribute to the Memphis workers and King.

    It's been 45 years since Martin Luther King Jr. was killed after coming to Memphis, Tenn., to support the sanitation workers' strike. Two of the men who demonstrated in the streets that day spoke with NBC's Ann Curry about their fight to make a better community for their families.

    8 comments

    This racism has to stop. Dr. King gave his life to rid this country of our Predjudices. As a white man I am often labeled as a hillbilly, redneck, or racist. Truth is, is that I'm none of those. I'm upper middle class and I judge people based on their character, and not their looks.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: civil-rights, martin-luther-king-jr, photography, us-news, featured, nightly-news, 1968, richard-copley
  • 8
    Mar
    2013
    7:47pm, EST

    Video: Why the Europeans are better at forecasting our weather than we are

    The predictions from European computer models, which have 10 times the computing ability of the National Weather Service, have increasingly become more accurate than our models with the starkest example being Hurricane Sandy. NBC's Al Roker reports.

    1 comment

    ... because European Pig Brother (big brother) wants to snoop into others' businesses?

    Show more
    Explore related topics: weather, forecasts, nightly-news
  • 4
    Feb
    2013
    11:03am, EST

    Moms Bloom: Making a Difference for new moms

    A volunteer group made up of mother's called "Moms Bloom" in Grand Rapids, Michigan, gives help and support to new mothers. NBC's Mara Schiavocampo reports. 

    By Joo Lee, Producer, NBC News 

    It's crazy. It's nonstop! I feel like it's a marathon." That's how Raechel Morrow, a mother of toddler twins and a newborn describes life as a stay-at-home mom. Sound familiar?

    When we met Morrow and her adorable little trio one morning in late October, I had just finished drinking my first coffee of the day. Watching her play with her children, read, feed, hold, soothe, change and chase them... two hours later, even I wanted to take a nap! The caffeine in my cup was no match for their  boundless level of energy.

    "It's really hard. That's the truth," Morrow said with a laugh.


    "Everybody wants to pay attention to the baby but mom is the one who really needs the support, often times," Sara Binkley-Tow said.

    Five years ago, Binkley-Tow founded a non-profit called Moms Bloom in Grand Rapids, Michigan.  It's a program that provides free help for new moms. They conduct full background checks and offer training to their volunteers. It's not a babysitting service. It's about nurturing moms during the first few months of a newborn's arrival so they can nurture their children.

    Binkley-Tow calls her group "the extended family for the 21st century."

    Raechel Morrow's closest relatives live three hours away. Her husband works during the day. Moms Bloom connected Morrow with volunteer Becky Brink, a retired teacher who has two adult children of her own. Brink visits Morrow once or twice a week.

    "I'm usually playing with the kids while mom gets the laundry done or takes a nap," Brink said.

    Brink is not just an extra set of hands, she is also a supportive and listening ear.

    "If the mom's not healthy and balanced, the mom can't take care of the family," Morrow said.

    She says that having Brink there "means the world."

    As I write this, I'm thinking of my sister, a mother of two small boys who lives 3,000 miles away. I wish there was a Moms Bloom in every town.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: newborns, parenting, featured, nightly-news, moms-bloom
  • 2
    Feb
    2013
    7:26pm, EST

    The Gatorade shower: An enduring symbol of athletic victory

    The history of the Gatorade shower tradition from some of the people who created and experienced it.

    By Allison Flicker, NBC News

    At the end of a football game, players are usually covered in mud, dirt and grass stains. A football coach, however, hopes to be covered in just one thing – Gatorade. 

    The Gatorade shower is an iconic sports tradition on playing fields across the country. 

    “Hey, forget the medals and the letter sweater,” Chicago Bears defensive lineman Dan Hampton said.  The “universal sign of achievement” is dunking the coach.


    The tradition first started with Hampton and the 1984 Chicago Bears.

    “When I dumped it on [Coach Mike] Ditka, you could see him fighting it off, and he had no idea,” Hampton said. “You have to remember, this was the first time that it had ever been attempted.”

    Two years later, the New York Giants made the new practice a tradition. Their coach, Bill Parcells, was very superstitious, so as they continued to win, they continued to dump Gatorade on him.

    “He knew it was coming from somewhere,” Giants linebacker Harry Carson said. “He just didn't know exactly where, or if I was going to be wearing my uniform, or somebody's coat, or somebody's hat, but he knew it was coming.”

    Carson said the Gatorade shower isn’t to parade a win over the opposing team. 

    “You know, doing it, wasn't so much about rubbing it into the face of our opponent,” Carson said. “It was a symbol of love and affection that we had for our coach.”

    Indianapolis Colts Coach Tony Dungy soaked in tradition.

    “I really wasn’t expecting it but it’s a good feeling to know that you’ve accomplished something that they players feel is worthy of pouring the bucket on you,” Dungy said.

    When asked if he had ever tried to buck the tradition, Dungy said he hadn’t.

    “No, not at all. Because you know once you get over that initial shock of being so cold you realize, ‘Hey, these guys believe we've done something special.’ The overall feeling that, wow, we've accomplished something unique,” Dungy said.

    Miami Dolphins Coach Don Shula, however, was not such a fan.

    “[It] didn't have a lot of class to it,” Shula said. “And I'd prefer to be carried off the field.”

    Shula, though, knows the technique for a proper Gatorade shower.

    “Somebody will come around to get the coach's attention and talk to them seriously about something that's going on the field,” Shula explained. “So now the coach has to give that player all of his attention. And then the Gatorade comes and dunks him.”

    The Giants’ Carson said he made sure his coach had removed his headset before dousing him.

    “What I wanted to do was get the Gatorade on his head, not on his neck,” Carson said. “I wanted to see it really splash down from the heavens from the top of his head, to cover the whole upper half of his torso.”

    Almost three decades later, the Gatorade shower is a symbolic part of any athletic victory celebration – especially on the football field. 

    “Somebody had to be the first one to put the star on top of the tree, right?” Hampton said.

    So who will get the Gatorade shower at Super Bowl XLVII?

    “I'm going to go out on a limb and say it’s going to be Coach Harbaugh,” Hampton said jokingly.

    Carson did not offer a prediction but did offer some expert advice to the winning players and coach.

    “If that coach is getting dumped, he should be thrilled and extremely happy that he is getting dumped because losers don't get dumped,” Carson said. “Just let that coach feel the exhilaration of winning.” 

    About 1,500 police officers are fanning across New Orleans ahead of the Super Bowl on Sunday – the city's first Super Bowl since Hurricane Katrina more than seven years ago. NBC's Janet Shamlian reports.

    5 comments

    Show more
    Explore related topics: super-bowl, harbaugh, featured, gatorade, nightly-news
  • 27
    Jan
    2013
    7:57pm, EST

    Schools receive guidance on including students with disabilities in sports

    The Department of Education released new guidelines on how to integrate students with disabilities into sports —which has been a struggle for cash-strapped schools. NBC's Rehema Ellis reports.

    By Erica Ayisi, NBC News

    Adam McGouirk is 13 years old. He’s in the 8th grade and like many middle school students, he loves sports. 

    Adam has been playing basketball and handball for a few years now, despite having spastic cerebral palsy. Spastic cerebral palsy affects Adam’s lower extremities impairs his movements, coordination and balance. His neurological condition makes it challenging for him to join his school’s sports teams -- but that will change next school year, as the Department of Education recently announced new guidelines for integrating students with disabilities into school sports. 

    Secretary of Education Arne Duncan stated on his blog, “We make clear that schools may not exclude students who have an intellectual, developmental, physical, or any other disability from trying out and playing on a team, if they are otherwise qualified.” 


    The guidance states that “the law does not require that a student with a disability be allowed to participate in any selective or competitive program offered by a school district, so long as the selection or competition criteria are not discriminatory.” 

    Adam plays sports for a private league. Shooting hoops has made him stronger and could help him playing at school with his friends. 

    “It would be a wonderful experience for schools,” Adam said. “They want to just play sports and be supportive.”  

    Courtesy of the McGourick family

    Since Adam started playing basketball for the Henry County Hurricanes, his upper body strength has increased immensely -- at times he’s able to get around with just a cane. His coach, Harlon Matthews, is in charge of wheel chair sports and he agrees. Matthews says Adam is making strides physically and socially. He says students like Adam just want equality. 

    Coach Harlon would know – he too is in a wheelchair. 

    Courtesy McGouirk family

    Adam McGouirk plays basketball and handball.

    “We don’t want anything above and we don’t want anything below,” Matthews said. “I don’t want anything extra-just help these kids be a part of something that’s very meaningful and impactful for their lives.” Questions remain, however: How much will it cost schools to integrate students with disabilities? Will this directive include students with both cognitive and physical disabilities? Nevertheless, students and parents are looking forward to the changes. 

    Bryan McGouirk, Adam’s father, hopes this directive will give more voice to students with disabilities. “Some people seem to have the misunderstanding that kids with disabilities are going to be placed into some regular athletics and that’s not we’re looking for at all,” McGouirk. “We’re looking for a separate and defined program that our kids can compete in.” 

    2 comments

    My son plays on the Henry Hurricanes team with Adam. I can tell you from personal experience what a positive opportunity this directive is for students with disabilities of all types.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: sports, disabilities, nightly-news, arne-duncan
  • 7
    Dec
    2012
    5:12pm, EST

    Making a Difference: three nonprofits report a spike in donations

    As a result of coverage on 'Nightly News,' three nonprofits are reporting that they received far more donations than normal. NBC's Katy Tur reports.

    Three organizations profiled during NBC Nightly News' Making a Difference series said they've raised far more in donations that they typically do as a result of Nightly's coverage. If you'd like to take a look at the original stories, we've re-posted them below along with links to the organizations' websites. 

    One Simple Wish is an organization that grants wishes to foster children. 

    An organization called One Simple Wish has granted the wishes of more than 3000 foster children, providing a small piece of joy to kids still in need of a permanent family. NBC's Anne Thompson reports.

    The Starkey Hearing Foundation assists those with hearing loss.

     

    Stephanie Montalvo has been legally deaf since birth, but the 15-year-old is now able to hear -- thanks to an organization that helps kids get hearing devices their families would not ordinarily be able to afford. NBC's Chelsea Clinton reports.

    And the Graybeards are raising money for the victims of Hurricane Sandy.

    A group of firefighters, cops, executives and others who have made it their mission help even when they're off duty, are raising money for the victims of Hurricane Sandy. NBC's Katy Tur reports.

     

    1 comment

    This is wonderful!!!! I cried after I saw these stories and had to step up to help. I encourage you to do the same please. Thank you!!!

    Show more
    Explore related topics: donations, featured, making-a-difference, nightly-news, starkey-hearing-foundation, one-simple-wish, graybeards
  • 9
    Nov
    2012
    7:14pm, EST

    Recovery and loss on Staten Island

    Those who lost their homes during Hurricane Sandy are salvaging what they can from the wreckage, and trying to stay afloat financially as they cope with the aftermath of the storm. NBC's Ann Curry reports.

    In case you missed it, last night on "NBC Nightly News" Ann Curry visited residents of Staten Island who are still suffering in the wake of Hurricane Sandy. If you would like to help any of the families mentioned in the report, please click on the links below to learn more.

    Help Jen and Pedro Correa rebuild
    How to help the Wright family
    Donate to the Puglias

     

    3 comments

    One more thing, Brian, as it just occurred to me that President Obama cited the film in his UN Speech which was September 25 or 26. Right? Freedom of Speech, etc.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: ann-curry, staten-island, featured, nightly-news, hurricane-sandy
  • 22
    Oct
    2012
    8:20pm, EDT

    Boy Scout's goal: Interview 1,000 World War II vets

    Rehema Ellis, NBC NEws writes

    Kyle Miller hasn’t been around long enough to have much of his own history, but at 16, he’s deeply involved in the military history that others created.

    When he was 12, Kyle, a Boy Scout, joined a group for World War II veterans. He was so fascinated by their stories that he became their archivist. Now he’s taken on an even bigger task to make certain their stories are around forever.

    Three WWII veterans tell how they fulfilled their duty to country.

    “At the beginning it would seem kind of strange to befriend somebody who’s three-quarters of a century older than me. But, when you really start talking to them, you realize they’re no different than you are,” he said.


    Kyle’s great-grandfather fought in the Battle of the Bulge, a major German offensive in France, Luxembourg and Belgium during the winter of 1944-45. He died when Kyle was 4-years-old. Being around veterans, Kyle said, he gets to experience what his great-grandfather might have shared with him.

    “I realized what heroes they truly are, how much they sacrificed for their families, their country and for people like me,” he said.

    To honor them, this young man from Pickerington, Ohio got the idea to collect the stories of 1,000 veterans of World War II and post them on a website he designed with his father, who is also his Scout leader.

    The project is called Voices from the Front. The project will also help him the attain the highest Boy Scout rank, Eagle Scout, which requires he demonstrate leadership while carrying out a community service project. He will also earn academic credit from his mother, who homeschools Kyle and his four siblings.

    “There are a lot of books out there that have captured a lot of stories but there’s a lot we don’t have, so this project is to get and capture more of the stories before the veterans die,” Kyle said. “There are always stories out there that we’re missing.”

    Among them, he said, stories about what was going on at home while the men were in battle.

    “You can always read about the battle strategy, but you don’t get the real personal aspect of it,” he said. “From the wives and people at home, all the way to the support units, and then onto the combat units. We want to capture all those stories to hear all those perspectives.

    With the help of volunteers, Kyle hopes to reach his goal of 1,000 voices by next fall. Meanwhile, Kyle has a new goal: To finish a book about veterans of the Battle of the Bulge.

    13 comments

    I enjoyed the piece about the Boy Scout getting oral histories of World War II veterans. You might want to look into the group Veterans Heritage Project - - that has been doing the same this, but on a much larger scale, for the past eight years.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: war, world-war-ii, making-a-difference, nightly-news, rehema-ellis
  • 16
    Oct
    2012
    6:23am, EDT

    Mystery kidney disease decimates Central America sugarcane workers

    An inexplicable epidemic in Central America, where more than 16,000 people — mostly sugarcane workers — have died from incurable chronic kidney disease. NBC's Kerry Sanders reports from Nicaragua.

    Kerry Sanders and Lisa Riordan Seville writes

    CHICHIGALPA, Nicaragua – You won’t see a road sign pointing to “La Isla de Viudas,” or “The Island of Widows,” as it’s not the community’s official name. It’s a nickname born from a horrific body count. 

    In the past 10 years, it’s believed that hundreds, if not thousands, of residents of Chichigalpa — mostly male sugarcane workers — have died from chronic kidney disease, or CKD. That in a city of nearly 60,000, roughly the size of Ames, Iowa. 

    The mysterious and hidden epidemic, first highlighted by the Center for Public Integrity, has claimed thousands more lives across Central America. In El Salvador and Nicaragua alone, the number of men dying from the excruciatingly painful disease has risen five-fold in the last two decades. High rates of CKD also have been found in rural villages in India and among the rice paddies of Sri Lanka.


    Sacorro Mendez Flores, who lives in the “La Isla” district of Chichigalpa, remembers when her son first fell ill. Jorge Luis Silva didn’t look sick at first, but inside he was dying. His kidneys struggled to filter waste from his body, to no avail. Five months ago, Flores buried him. 

    “The same thing happened to my husband,” she said. “They both died the same.”

    Sacorro Mendez-Flores, surrounded by her grandchildren, holds a family photo. The resident of Chichigalpa, Nicaragua, lost both her son and husband to chronic kidney disease.

    Researchers are searching for answers about why this disease is ravaging not only the bodies of its victims, but the communities they leave behind. 

    The illness spreads
    More than 20 million Americans aged 20 and older have chronic kidney disease, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. In developed countries like the U.S., CKD often goes hand in hand with obesity, diabetes and hypertension. With treatment, including dialysis and kidney transplants, many with the disease survive. 

    The CKD plaguing parts of Central America, however, is something scientists have never seen before.

    “It affects people who don't have diabetes or hypertension, which are the usual risk factors for chronic kidney disease,” said Sasha Chavkin, a CPI reporter who has covered the mysterious epidemic for several years. “No one can figure out what it is that's making all these people sick.”

    Slideshow: Mysterious malady fells sugarcane workers

    Estbean Felix / AP

    Workers in Central American sugarcane fields are dying of chronic kidney disease at an astonishing rate and experts are unable to say why.

    Launch slideshow

    “It comes at great social, economic and humanitarian cost,” said Dr. Daniel R. Brooks, an associate professor of epidemiology at the Boston University School of Health who is leading a research team looking for the cause of the epidemic. “These are working-age people who are being struck down, and whole communities are really hurt and devastated by this disease.” 

    And with little or no access to the life-saving treatments available in the developed world, a CKD diagnosis is often tantamount to a death sentence. 

    Related stories

    In Nicaraguan sugarcane community, workers stare death in the face

    Chronic kidney disease: 'Silent killer' may have multiple triggers

    “Where we stand right now is that ultimately this disease is not treatable in this community,” said Nate Raines, a researcher with the Mt. Sinai School of Medicine Global Health program, which is collaborating with two organizations in Nicaragua on research independent from the Boston University group. “What we need to do is find the cause. That's the only way to really help the health situation.” 

    Many in Chichigalpa believe that the root of the disease lies in chemicals sprayed in the sugarcane fields while men are working, or seeping into the water supply. A spokesperson from the sugar industry says the chemicals used are standard fertilizer and are not used to excess.  

    Science, so far, points to a more complicated answer. 

    'Markers' of kidney damage found
    The research team from the Boston University has linked the disease in Central America to strenuous labor, dehydration and environmental conditions in which chemicals may play a role. That theory was supported by the group’s most recent study, which found “markers” of kidney damage in adolescents as young as 12 in affected communities. 

    Thousands of miles away, research in Sri Lanka’s affected communities also indicates chemicals may play a key role in the illness devastating communities there.

    As reported last month by the Center for Public Integrity, the country’s health ministry and World Health Organization announced in June that a years-long study had identified chemicals thought to be an essential cause of the disease: cadmium and arsenic. Both are heavy metals found in fertilizers and pesticides that can cause an array of health effects, including the type of kidney damage ravaging communities in Sri Lanka and Nicaragua.

    While most of those tested had lower levels of the toxic elements than officially designated as dangerous by the United Nations, researchers believe that long-term exposure, likely through the food chain, may explain the high incidence of CDK. 

    Why are thousands of sugarcane workers dying from chronic kidney disease each year? Sasha Chavkin, of The Center for Public Integrity, discusses the search for the cause of this mysterious epidemic.

    The findings, due to be officially released in October, represent a potential breakthrough in the research about CDK worldwide, including the epidemic in Nicaragua. 

    Researchers in Central America have not pinpointed a chemical cause. But the new research on adolescents indicates the kidneys of those going into the fields may already be damaged, making the long days and repeated dehydration in the fields potentially deadly. 

    Some experts also suggest that sugarcane workers may also unwittingly be harming themselves as they struggle to stay hydrated while cutting up to 11 tons of cane a day by hand.

    For a refreshing pick-me-up, they occasionally slice a stalk of cane, peeling back its “bark” and sticking it in their mouths, where it produces a sweet sugary liquid. 

    But investigators now wonder: Could that constant flow of sucrose, combined with 90-plus degree temperatures and severe daily dehydration, be a deadly cocktail that slowly brings on CKD? 

    “We believe high amounts of sugar solutions may not cause much kidney damage,” said Dr. Richard Johnson, head of the division of renal disease and hypertension at the University of Colorado, Denver. “But under certain circumstances, such as dehydration, we’re concerned the sugar may actually be toxic in causing damage to the kidneys.”

    The sugar link
    Whether or not sugar consumption plays a direct role in causing the Central American form of CKD, activists say it is a thread that connects the disease to its northern cousin.

    In the U.S., rampant sugar consumption – Americans eat an average of 22.2 teaspoons of sugar per day according to the American Heart Association—drives many of the diseases linked to CKD, including diabetes and hypertension. 

    And with recent steep increases in the price and demand for sugar, more people are working longer hours in the sugarcane fields of Central America. In 2011, the U.S. imported 330,000 metric tons of raw sugar from Central America, or nearly one-quarter of total raw sugar imports that year, according to the United States Department of Agriculture.

    “Not only is the production of sugar killing people, but the consumption of it is killing people,” said Jason Glaser of La Isla Foundation, a nonprofit group he founded to focus attention on the epidemic and fund research that he hopes will solve the mystery. “It's bad for you and it's bad for workers.” 

    The sugar industry, however, rejects suggestions that it is causing the epidemic of CKD among workers at its mills and plantations.

    “We are not responsible for it,” said Mario Amador, a spokesman for the sugarcane industry. “We’re working to find a solution.”

    He also blames the workers themselves, saying they drink too much alcohol. “It’s part of our culture,” Amador said. “It’s part of the things we do in our country. Poor people do it a lot.” 

    Amador also speculated that active volcanoes in the region could have contaminated the water supply. But he admits he does not know why so many have died from CKD.

    No matter what the research finds, Central America is unlikely to curb its cane production anytime soon. The world market for sugar is strong, and the industry receives direct help from abroad. 

    The International Finance Corp., the private-sector arm of the World Bank, has provided loans of more than $100 million to promote production and biofuel in Nicaragua in recent years. Though the loans went to two plantations whose workers have been heavily affected by kidney disease, they were approved without formal consideration of the disease because the IFC did not find a link between the cane fields and CKD, according to the Associated Press. 

    After workers complained about the loans, the IFC helped to negotiate an $800,000 donation to sponsor the ongoing Boston University study, the Center for Public Integrity reported. The money was provided by Nicaragua Sugar Estates Limited, a major sugar producer in the west of the country, part of more than $4 million it has committed toward research and community development in recent years.

    Waiting to die
    But for many in Chichigalpa, the results of the research – whatever they may be – will come too late. 

    Like most of the men in this community, Maximiliano Lopez, spent years in the fields cutting sugarcane. He began at 5 a.m., when the air was cool, and continued to work as the sun beat down, sometimes logging 14 hours a day. Then he was informed he had CKD.

    In his own words, Maximiliano Lopez describes an average day in the life of a sugarcane cutter and how he's coping with the chronic kidney disease that he expects will soon kill him.

    Even after his diagnosis, which bans him from working in the fields or at the mill, the muscular 32-year-old said he used a friend’s identification to return to cutting cane. Nicaragua is the second-poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, he explained, and many workers continue to work the harvest after being diagnosed with kidney disease because it is the only work they can find. 

    “A lot of people do it out of necessity,” Lopez said. “They have a big family and they're the head of the household, so even if they're sick, you have to find work to support your family.” 

    But, as Lopez and other cane workers eventually discovered, short-term survival may mean leaving behind the families that they labored so mightily to support.

    “I began working there to earn a living and instead I earned death,” he said. “I’m just waiting for the day to come.” 

    More from Open Channel:

  • Rep. Jesse Jackson Jr. investigated for possible financial improprieties
  • Why did environmental nonprofit donate to conservative pro-coal group?
  • Doping agency paints Armstrong as leader of long-running cheating scheme
  • 100 Reporters: Suicide epidemic among American Indian youth
  • Satellite images appear to reveal CIA's secret bin Laden training ground
  • Big donors give far and wide, influencing out-of-state races and issues
  • Deadly crossing: Death toll rises among those desperate for American dream
  • Profiles of terror suspects sent from UK to US to face trial
  • Up for grabs: $300 million estate of reclusive heiress Huguette Clark
  •  

    Follow Open Channel from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook

     

     

     

    201 comments

    “We are not responsible for it,” said Mario Amador, a spokesman for the sugarcane industry. “We’re working to find a solution.” Hmmmm...I think Mario and other people like him, lying about peoples lives so that the industry they represent can make a few more bucks o …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: nicaragua, world, health, cane, sugarcane, nightly-news, kerry-sanders, open-channel, commentid-featured
  • 31
    Aug
    2012
    6:31pm, EDT

    A fond farewell to video editor Rich Clark

    After 37 years of working on stories for the NBC News Washington bureau, video editor Rich Clark is retiring after tonight's broadcast.

    Several years into his tenure, Rich began numbering every tape he put into an editing machine. He watched the tape technology evolve, and the machines become more sophisticated and speedy; and today when we took a photograph of one of the last tapes Rich handled, his count had reached almost 40,000.

    That's a mind-boggling number in a business that is as ephemeral as ours, but Rich stood out all of those years for his solid, steady, quiet professionalism. One veteran put it like this: When a young producer came into Rich's edit room and was unsteady and inexperienced, Rich raised that producer's work up, taught the producer new ways of looking at things, and made that producer better. When an older producer came into Rich's room, frenzied and determined to stake out new visual heights, Rich calmed that producer down with a steady hand and guided the producer back to calm waters and realistic goals.

    Rich Clark taught a lot of "Nightly News" producers, and producers for other NBC network broadcasts, a  brand of journalism that they could be proud of, and never wavered from his dedication to excellence. Like most veterans, he was a stickler for the fundamentals. From visual clarity to good grammar, he led a generation of journalists. We will miss him, and we wish him well.

    5 comments

    Brian, As always a terrific broadcast. The 2012 election may decide either the renewing of America or the dismantling of America. It can be the point of no return. Have a nice day and I look forward to Nightly News this evening because NBC will always be there to report Breaking News.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: featured, video-editor, nightly-news, rich-clark
Older posts

Browse

  • featured,
  • nnam,
  • nn,
  • updated,
  • making-a-difference,
  • nightly-news,
  • afghanistan,
  • syria,
  • military,
  • list,
  • barack-obama,
  • appfeatured,
  • education,
  • richard-engel,
  • crime,
  • north-korea,
  • china,
  • egypt,
  • brian-williams,
  • nbc-nightly-news,
  • white-house,
  • space,
  • russia,
  • kevin-tibbles,
  • israel,
  • shooting,
  • first-read,
  • capitol-hill,
  • texas,
  • decision-2012,
  • robert-bazell,
  • ayman-mohyeldin,
  • mark-potter,
  • lester-holt,
  • us-news,
  • aurora,
  • assad,
  • bp,
  • world,
  • boston-marathon-tragedy,
  • oil,
  • ian-williams,
  • weather,
  • chelsea-clinton,
  • olympics
Also

Top NBCNews.com headlines

3147,10
Advertise | AdChoices

Brian Williams

Brian Williams is the seventh anchor and managing editor in the history of "NBC Nightly News," which represents the largest single daily source of news in America.

Brian Williams Blogroll

  • NBC Nightly News Website
  • NBC Nightly News on Twitter
  • NBC Nightly News on Facebook
  • First Read
  • World Blog
  • Field Notes
  • Photos, behind the scenes, reporting
  • BriTunes

Archives

  • 2013
    • May (17)
    • April (39)
    • March (27)
    • February (34)
    • January (39)
  • 2012
    • December (26)
    • November (13)
    • October (44)
    • September (26)
    • August (37)
    • July (43)
    • June (38)
    • May (55)
    • April (58)
    • March (60)
    • February (62)
    • January (56)
  • 2011
    • December (30)
    • November (36)
    • October (28)
    • September (23)
    • August (28)
    • July (34)
    • June (42)
    • May (54)
    • April (43)
    • March (50)
    • February (45)
    • January (52)
  • 2010
    • December (58)
    • November (52)
    • October (48)
    • September (50)
    • August (68)
    • July (43)
    • June (55)
    • May (47)
    • April (39)
    • March (38)
    • February (33)
    • January (45)
  • 2009
    • December (38)
    • November (36)
    • October (43)
    • September (39)
    • August (40)
    • July (54)
    • June (42)
    • May (39)
    • April (46)
    • March (48)
    • February (44)
    • January (48)
  • 2008
    • December (52)
    • November (57)
    • October (56)
    • September (45)
    • August (53)
    • July (54)
    • June (48)
    • May (52)
    • April (62)
    • March (48)
    • February (59)
    • January (64)
  • 2007
    • December (62)
    • November (70)
    • October (103)
    • September (124)
    • August (112)
    • July (108)
    • June (109)
    • May (99)
    • April (72)
    • March (92)
    • February (86)
    • January (81)
  • 2006
    • December (87)
    • November (89)
    • October (95)
    • September (75)
    • August (127)
    • July (110)
    • June (83)
    • May (87)
    • April (95)
    • March (93)
    • February (99)
    • January (176)
  • 2005
    • December (72)
    • November (113)
    • October (85)

Most Commented

  • White House releases additional documents related to Benghazi response (886)
  • 'Spirit of the Cold War': Russia says US diplomat was trying to recruit for CIA (322)
  • Holder faces questions on Capitol Hill (398)
  • Sisters, separated for 17 years, find each other at high school track meet (105)
  • No cellphone, no Wi-Fi: Living in America's quietest place (100)
  • 'We saved the ship': WWII vets gather, likely for last time (79)

Other blogs

  • Daily Nightly
  • The Maddow Blog
  • The Last Word
  • Hardblogger
  • First Read
  • World Blog
  • Field Notes
  • Inside Dateline
  • Behind the Wall
  • The Ed Show
  • Morning Joe
  • Daily Rundown

NBCNews.com top stories

3147,10
© 2013 NBCNews.com
  • Nightly News on NBCNews.com
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Site map
  • Careers
  • Closed captioning
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertise